


Stephanie Carroll
Licensed Agent and Office Manager

Jennifer Lemponen
Commercial Lines Specialist

Sue Marie Kyko
Commercial Insurance Agent

Nichole Johnston
Personal Lines Specialist

Tony Cusati
President
ABOUT US
High-quality
team focused
on your
unique needs.
Good insurance is not just about policies. It is about people who know what to look for, how to explain it, and when to step in.
That is exactly how our team delivers peace of mind - through attentive service, thoughtful guidance, and a genuine commitment to protecting what matters most.
Steady in uncertain times, precise in the details, and deeply rooted in trust, our pros work to ensure every plan is tailored with intention.


OTHER
Every now and then, life calls for an extra hand — and that’s where we step in. We’ve gathered trusted, high-quality professionals personally recommended by our customers and team — services that also strive to offer their very best right here in our community.
It’s our way of simplifying life while supporting the local businesses that keep our area thriving. Have a favorite to share? Tell us all about it!
HOMETOWN
SERVICES

Through every act of care, we’re working to build something bigger than business: a culture of kindness, quality, and connection. Join us in spreading hope and opportunity – because being a good neighbor means showing up with heart and purpose.
Hope Starts at Home: Humphrey Insurance Supports Ashtabula Dream Center
For us, true coverage goes beyond policies – it touches lives. Right here in our community, families, individuals, and animals alike need compassion and support. That’s why we proudly take part in efforts that make a real difference.

Stay sharp with something we’ve created just for you. Covering tips, reminders, and stories that make everyday life a little easier to navigate.
Each edition is filled with inspiring ideas, and simple ways to feel balanced, stay positive, and pay that same energy forward. A caring read, designed to brighten your month.








Sarah Warner







Niki Gregory







Kenneth Houck







ryan Schwentker







Debra Mackall







Brenda Ratliff







Hank Kas







Jeremy Murphy







Liz Hagerman







Keith Winn







John W







Chris Mixer







Marie Schulz







Cyndi Osche







Margaret Adams







Dan Kaluza







Roger Marple







carol martin







Joel Reyes







Ray Mattson







Darcy Wright







L. Kevin McGinnis







Michael Brown







Toni Prasek







Stephanie Carroll







Stephanie Carroll







queen marsh







James Smith







Jeremy Carroll







Steve Swanson







Dick Schelat







Anet Adao







Daniel Calaway







C Webb







Alexander Arvanites







Jason Bernardo







Dennis Kane







Valerie Markgraf







Antoinette Jones







john schmaltz







Jim H







Nancy Snyder







Gloria Boyd







Trey Reed







Tracy Tisdale







Jeff Locher







David Nolan







laura stroud







Colleen Knapp







Michael Parsons

WHY US?
When
life happens,
Humphrey
handles it...
Quickly!
Trust is at the heart of everything we do. Accidents, surprises, questions, gaps, claims, changes, this is where a good agency earns its keep. We bring the know-how, the options, and the calm.
We're not just here for life's surprises - we're constantly working behind the scenes to keep you protected. From reviewing your coverage as life evolves to staying ahead of industry changes, we're always focused on your best interests.









