WHY US?

When

life happens,

Humphrey

handles it...

Quickly!

Trust is at the heart of everything we do. Accidents, surprises, questions, gaps, claims, changes, this is where a good agency earns its keep. We bring the know-how, the options, and the calm.

We're not just here for life's surprises - we're constantly working behind the scenes to keep you protected. From reviewing your coverage as life evolves to staying ahead of industry changes, we're always focused on your best interests.

BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION

POLICIES

For the
people
you love
and life
you built

Auto+Toys

Home

Life

Business

• RV Insurance

• Boat Insurance

• Motorcycle Insurance

• Auto Insurance

Request an estimate

Tony Cusati

President

Nichole Johnston

Licensed Agent/Notary

Jennifer Lemponen

Commercial Lines Specialist

Sue Marie Kyko

Commercial Insurance Agent

Stephanie Carroll

Licensed Agent and Office Manager

ABOUT US

High-quality

team focused

on your

unique needs.

Good insurance is not just about policies. It is about people who know what to look for, how to explain it, and when to step in.

That is exactly how our team delivers peace of mind - through attentive service, thoughtful guidance, and a genuine commitment to protecting what matters most.

Steady in uncertain times, precise in the details, and deeply rooted in trust, our pros work to ensure every plan is tailored with intention.

MEET US

OTHER

Every now and then, life calls for an extra hand — and that’s where we step in. We’ve gathered trusted, high-quality professionals personally recommended by our customers and team — services that also strive to offer their very best right here in our community.

It’s our way of simplifying life while supporting the local businesses that keep our area thriving. Have a favorite to share? Tell us all about it!

HOMETOWN

SERVICES

CONCIERGE

A handy

list of

great

businesses!

SEARCH DIRECTORY

SUGGEST A BUSINESS

A BIG HEART FOR

OUR COMMUNITY

Through every act of care, we’re working to build something bigger than business: a culture of kindness, quality, and connection. Join us in spreading hope and opportunity – because being a good neighbor means showing up with heart and purpose.

Hope Starts at Home: Humphrey Insurance Supports Ashtabula Dream Center

For us, true coverage goes beyond policies – it touches lives. Right here in our community, families, individuals, and animals alike need compassion and support. That’s why we proudly take part in efforts that make a real difference.

COMMUNITY

Causes

that

matters

LEARN ABOUT CAUSE

MAGAZINE

Helpful

and cool
read for
modern
life

READ LATEST ISSUE

Stay sharp with something we’ve created just for you. Covering tips, reminders, and stories that make everyday life a little easier to navigate.

Each edition is filled with inspiring ideas, and simple ways to feel balanced, stay positive, and pay that same energy forward. A caring read, designed to brighten your month.

Quote

Happy ever after

REQUIRES A HUMPHREY INSURANCE AGENT

Peace of mind
starts here

Get the info you need
before moving forward,
Our pros are at yours
service

Consent to receive SMS. Msg & data rates may apply. Not required to purchase.

Thank you. We'll get back to you.

Error submitting the form.

HAPPY TO PROTECT YOU.

REVIEWS

Hear

it directly

from other

clients

SHARE YOUR OPINION

Yall have been so helpful
Thank you
Barry White

barry white

M Godwin

Amazing staff, recommended my friend after she had gotten dropped from another company due to an accident. Allstate not only took her in, but gave her the cheapest rates compared to all of the other insurance company’s she applied for. Would recommend them to anyone.

Kyrstin Williams

Great people

Michael Lane

Standifer Insurance Group is a respected, professional and supportive company. I was treated like family from day one. They worked closely with me to provide the best coverage possible for my vehicle and home owners policies. I would recommend them highly!

Lisa B (BamaLady0711)

They are always helpful whenever I’ve needed assistance and have prompt solutions to my issues

O Dee

Kathy Nelems-Marino

Loooove Allstate! My favorite is Jessup, he really knows his ish. I can always call and ask him with whatever questions I have. Thorough, efficient and kind. No lagging about. I can always count all Allstate.

Jessica Klein

Ed Russell

Ron Richardson

jane smith

Home 🏠 and Auto coverage they stand up for the little guy .

Linda Evans

A++. Kevin answered the phone the 1st time i called. no robot!! super satisfied as he definitely found my a great rate. i would and I do recommend him to everyone!

PS he continues to answer his phone.

Tammy Lee

Ginger Etheridge

Been with Allstate over 25 years....

Jim

Miranda Fohner

Shugie's Gourmet

Quality people, my needs are always met and in a very timely manor. You can't go wrong using them.

Chris Legare

MIKE ATKINSON

Great team. Really took care of all my insurance needs when i moved to Birmingham. Highly recommend!

Brasher Burbank

R. Denese Williams

Been with this company for years. They have excellent customer service. Would recommend to anyone.

Sandra Rhoten

Rondi Kirby

Lisa Powell

I HAVE BEEN WITH STANDIFER SINCE 2003 THROUGH 2 TORNADOS 1 GARAGE FIRE AND RV AND PONTOON DAMAGE THEY ARE THE BEST!

Will Quinn

I like the service of the Standifer agency so much that I took them with me when I moved from central Alabama up to Huntsville area, Home and auto.

Jamey Bice

Michael W Smith

I have found them to be very responsive to my needs

Debra Leo

Leisa Mummert

Tanesha B

They do a great job and are always willing to help me when I call!

William Gerald

They really bend over backwards to help.

Lee Franklin

Loghan Moore

Jennifer Key

Sartaria Jackson

Great price on home and auto. Very easy to work with. They did all the work. I just sat back and let them handle it.

Joey Guthrie

Harry Jarvis

Latissus Turner

Prompt service. Always just a quick email away.

Ashley Ginn

Very professional staff and friendly

T A

I’ve been with your insurance group for years, and the consistent level of service has been outstanding. Your team’s willingness to work with me on pricing has been both helpful and refreshing. The one claim I filed was handled quickly and without any hassle, which only reinforced my confidence in your support. I truly appreciate the reliability and customer-first approach.

Andres Bernal

They have always been very helpful and quick! Recommend!

Vance Brewer

Myrna Picogna

Exceptional service

David Akins

Ins to dang high $324
00 month

Larry Johnson

Rohith Reddy

Used them when they were in Helena. Had a problem over the weekend and needed to talk to someone ASAP. Come Monday I finally got Jessup who said he would not share an after hours emergency number with me. He did not want to be bothered about problems over the weekend. This review is completely true and happened around the year 2000 despite their reply calling this false. What happened was my home insurance payment I paid online was credited back to my bank on a Friday afternoon. Saturday when I saw this I tried calling them to see if my home was still insured. I could not get anyone and stayed home all weekend to make sure it did not burn down since I did not know if I was covered. My call to Jessup on Monday is completely true and happened. Also on that Monday I got new insurance elsewhere and my agents home number that he was happy to share if I ever had a problem after work hours.

ibcleve

I was with Allstate for almost 3 years, my Vehicle Insurance went up every 6 months and Homeowners every year. I asked my Agent why was my rates rising so high and he stated because of the cost of material and labor to replace everything. So I told him they need to find somebody else to buy their material from. I went to State Farm and got more coverage for almost $400 dollars less. Please don’t waste your time, they start out with a great rate and rise over time to unbelievable rates.

Anonymous

Will Sullivan

Not really interested in making the other party pay for something that was their fault.

Paul Contorno

Eddie Kaylor

Dawn Sontag

My husband and I had a phone meeting with Larry DePalma on Tuesday, 3/24/2025. We were reviewing an updated quote for homeowner's insurance. We had several questions about the insurance, flood insurance, standard versus premium offering, deductible, hurricane coverage, etc. Larry was extremely thorough and detailed. He answered all of our questions, and put us at ease. We have used Considine Sharer & Associates for years, as our broker for auto, homeowners and flood insurance. This is the first time we worked with Larry, and I recommend his services for their existing and future clients.

Ruth Feeney

Professional & friendly

Dennis Reagan

This Allstate office is always there to answer any questions you may have or to help you understand any issues that come up. They are all very professional and courteous.

Joe Cioffi

Bob & Donn's office take care of our autos and our umbrella policy most recently. They are quick to respond, know to look for exposure as well as costs . Very helpful and efficient. Owners are also great folks who contribute to community! Very pleased to work with them!

Tara McQuaid

Considine Sharer and Associates has always been professional and up front with their services and costs. That is all anyone can ask in a business that provides insurance to people!

Matthew Covey

Gail Anderson

melisa fillman

I have been a client of this office since 1983. For almost forty years, Allstate has provided the best insurance services, whether for home or auto.

Bernadette Dugan

Vanessa Costa

They assist me with everything I need and are very help and nice

Debra Ayala

***** Always 5 star service *****

Nicole Sabarese

All State in Lacey Township is the most helpful and friendly office I have ever visited. Bob is very knowledgeable and makes time for you when you need him to explain things to you. This is the insurance agent you want to do business with.

Joseph Micallef

Nancy Rainsford

Marian Smith

Great and freindly service, always willing to help!!

GUS FABIAN

I transferred my account from another agency because of their lack of interest in my needs for insurance on a new car. The agent in Forked River was able to provide my insurance needs quickly.

GIL THOMAS

Would highly recommend as always fantastic service. Bob is knowledgeable, efficient and personable.

Claire Carrodus

Frances Henry

Gerard Ruggiero

Best staff everyone treats you like family . They always help to awnser any questions .feel like I'm always the most important

Darlene Rosa

Fair rates for good drivers when combined with drive wise earned discounts.

TRACY CAMPOLATTARO

Robert S

Very unhappy with this agency. I cannot even tell you how many years we have had them and used them as they are local. My husband handled all the insurance. He passed away, so now I do it. They are ONLY an Allstate company. Since 1996 I filed two claims. The first claim in 2020, when EVERYONE had wind damage from that bad wind storm. My premium jumped to 4,700. Since my husband was still alive I had zero idea as to what normal premium would be. In 2023, I ha bad luck and my dishwasher broke leaving a flood of water that ruined my flooring and under my sink. I filed a claim, thinking that’s why you have insurance. I received a non renewal and now have until April 30 to get new insurance. My first call to them, no one returned, I called again and was told they’d call me back and nothing. I then called a third time and spoke with Robin who informed me she would have Patty call me the following day which she finally did do. They have an I don’t care attitude. Even knowing my husband passed, and being a long time customer not one I’m sorry for your loss or any effort to even attempt to get me reinstated or get me insured at a decent rate. They came back with a rate of $7000. INSANE. I would stay away from these people. They are quick to grab your money and write a policy but when an issue arises they certainly don’t fight for you or even give two craps. Terrible group! Left me high and dry and could care less. And FYI the carrier they wrote me with was National General and if you file even one claim for water over $10,000 they drop you. It’s written somewhere in their tiny print. This is what I was told, so you can have a company since 1996 and file two claims in 28 years and they dump you. Find another agency to deal with and stay away from Allstate who this company is married to. UODATE: FUNNY I WENT TO USAA ABD GOT THE SANE COVERAGE WITH NO ISSUE BEING INSURED FOR $2300 per year. AN ALLSTATE insurance company charging $4700 then wanting to up me to $7000 after dropping me for two claims in 28 years! Forbes Rated USAA in the top two. Thank you do dropping me after 28 years. I’m sorry my husband did not research this but he was terminal and your company is yet to say after 28 years of knowing him and getting our business, that you are sorry for the loss. I will stay with what I originally said, stay away from this broker.

Marie Buzzeo

Awesome Insurance Company

Florence Price

very professional

wijdan murrar

I highly recommend Donn and his team for your insurance. I switched from Geico to Allstate and couldn’t be more pleased. I saved money while increasing my coverage.

Kevin Sweetnam

Faith Hyland

Rich “fish tail” Mc Greg

Fabrizzio Orozco

Really good coverage, affordable, and accessible when we've had questions.

Kelle Franzen

Carol Naia

Shannon Walsh

I have been a customer of Donn Sharer for about 20 years. I started with Auto and then added Home Owner’s and Personal Umbrella policies along the way. Liz and Donn have helped me stay protected as my needs have changed over the years. I have received great customer service from them, from helping me find the right coverage to helping me with claims. It’s been a very professional experience with a personal touch. I know they will be there for me as I need them in the future. Thanks!

Marco De Sousa

Bob’s agency and staff are excellent! Very knowledgeable and help with anything I need.

Cory Case

Considine Sharer & Assoc. did a great job walking me through my policies to make sure the coverage was right for how my family and life have evolved. Adding an umbrella policy now gives me more piece of mind with my home, autos and family.

Joshua Hayek

Robin went above and beyond to help me. I have dealt with numerous Insurance Agencies on a professional level and she definitely has stood out. She is amazing!!

Cary Gardner

Since moving i have consolidated all my insurance needs with Allstate! Considine and Sharer are honest dependable and saved me money!

Daniel M Doka

Really helpfully and honest.

Kevin Sheridan

I have both Auto and home owners insurance with them . Everyone I have come into contact at this agency has been very professional and courteous. Extremely proactive in monitoring cost and keeping you up to date with changes in the industry and opportunities that may arise that can enhance coverage and more importantly save money. I have recommended them to a number of individuals in the past who decided to make a change and are now satisfied clients

John Arizzi

Bob is so thoughtful and knowledgeable. He really knows insurance and how to help people. He goes out of his way to provide information so you can make the best decision for you and your family. He genuinely cares about people and their situations. I highly recommend Bob and his team at Considine Sharer & Associates.

Christine Harashinski

I have an uncommon business to insure, but
Sharer & associates found me the right coverage at a very reasonable rate. I’m very happy with their exceptional performance…a friendly & competent staff. I highly recommend Sharer & Associates Allstate

Matthew Heft

Edward Phillips

My husband and I have been doing business with Donn Sharer for many years and we are very happy with the relationship we have forged with him and his office. Donn is extremely knowledgeable about his business and has provided sound recommendations regarding many different types of policies meant to protect us and our assets. Robin is also very knowledgeable, efficient, and a pleasure to deal with. We highly recommend Donn and his team for all your insurance needs.

Jennifer Breslin

Great agents! Exceptional service, answered all of my questions and got me a great price on home & car insurance bundle. I would highly recommend this agency to friends and family.

Dana Joris

Kevin Lynch

Paul Lynch

Great and helpful people answering all questions teach you and make you understand better