top of page
policies_background.png
POLICIES_WATERMARK.png

POLICIES

For the
people
you love
and life
you built

POLICIES_IMG.png

Auto+Toys

Home

Life

Business

• RV Insurance

• Boat Insurance

• Motorcycle Insurance

• Auto Insurance

ABOUTUS_BACKGROUND.png
Kayla_Stula.webp

Stephanie Carroll

Licensed Agent and Office Manager

Kayla_Stula.webp

Jennifer Lemponen

Commercial Lines Specialist

Kayla_Stula.webp

Sue Marie Kyko

Commercial Insurance Agent

Kayla_Stula.webp

Nichole Johnston

Personal Lines Specialist

Kayla_Stula.webp

Tony Cusati

President

ABOUT US

High-quality

team focused

on your

unique needs.

Good insurance is not just about policies. It is about people who know what to look for, how to explain it, and when to step in.
 
That is exactly how our team delivers peace of mind - through attentive service, thoughtful guidance, and a genuine commitment to protecting what matters most.

Steady in uncertain times, precise in the details, and deeply rooted in trust, our pros work to ensure every plan is tailored with intention.

CONC_BACKGROUND.png
CONC_WATERMARK.png

OTHER

Every now and then, life calls for an extra hand — and that’s where we step in. We’ve gathered trusted, high-quality professionals personally recommended by our customers and team — services that also strive to offer their very best right here in our community.

It’s our way of simplifying life while supporting the local businesses that keep our area thriving. Have a favorite to share? Tell us all about it!

HOMETOWN

SERVICES

CONCIERGE

A handy

list of

great

businesses!

CAUSE_BACKGROUND.png

A BIG HEART FOR

CAUSE_IMG_CROPPED.png

OUR COMMUNITY

Through every act of care, we’re working to build something bigger than business: a culture of kindness, quality, and connection. Join us in spreading hope and opportunity – because being a good neighbor means showing up with heart and purpose.

Hope Starts at Home: Humphrey Insurance Supports Ashtabula Dream Center

For us, true coverage goes beyond policies – it touches lives. Right here in our community, families, individuals, and animals alike need compassion and support. That’s why we proudly take part in efforts that make a real difference.

COMMUNITY

Causes

that

matters

BACKGROUND mag_review.png

MAGAZINE

Helpful

and cool
read for
modern
life

Stay sharp with something we’ve created just for you. Covering tips, reminders, and stories that make everyday life a little easier to navigate.

Each edition is filled with inspiring ideas, and simple ways to feel balanced, stay positive, and pay that same energy forward. A caring read, designed to brighten your month.

Cover_JanGIF (1).gif
HEADER_HOUSEWATERMARK.png
HEADER_PEEP4.png
HEADER_PEEP3.png
HEADER_PEEP2.png
HEADER_PEEP1.png
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Happy ever after

REQUIRES A HUMPHREY INSURANCE AGENT

Peace of mind
starts here

Get the info you need
before moving forward,
Our pros are at yours
service

Consent to receive SMS. Msg & data rates may apply. Not required to purchase.

Thank you. We'll get back to you.

Error submitting the form.

HEADER_LOGO.png
REVIEWS_PEEP.png

REVIEWS

Hear

it directly

from other

clients

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I recently switched my car insurance and had a great experience. Stephanie was easy to work with, very helpful, and answered all my questions. She made everything simple and stress-free.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Sarah Warner

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Tom is very helpful. found the right insurance for me

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Niki Gregory

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Sue kyko, the insurance agent at Humphrey insurance went above and beyond to provide great service and a great price for my homeowner.Insurance. she was able to save me almost $800.
On my yearly premium.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Kenneth Houck

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Really helpful

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

ryan Schwentker

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Friend highly recommended Humphrey insurance. Glad that we got an estimate from them. Saving us over $100 a month. Great service, great follow up and friendly staff.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Debra Mackall

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I'm just starting with them but so far,so good.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Brenda Ratliff

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I spoke with Tom Jackson at the Humphrey agency yesterday and I’m delighted to tell you after contacting many agencies that were of no help. Tom told me right away he could help me and he did.. He has gained a lifelong customer and everyone I know will know about him and the Humphrey agency. He gave me five star service and deserved every bit of it. Thank you again Tom for your help.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Hank Kas

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Monthly house payment went from 150 to 300 without notification or warning. Will be switching to a different insurance provider right away.
ZERO STARS. DO NOT RECOMMEND.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Jeremy Murphy

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Humphrey Insurance is an excellent insurance agency. I just switched from another agency, the transition went smoothly and I saved money on home and auto insurance. Great people working there!

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Liz Hagerman

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Great insurance company with this great agency . They listen. They care. They take immediate action. Rates are low and the service is excellent!

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Keith Winn

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

John W

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Awesome people, since I started driving they are the Only place that I have ever had insurance through. No need to go anywhere else.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Chris Mixer

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Humphrey ins. Went above and beyond to take care of all my needs when I bundled my home and car . And health insurance.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Marie Schulz

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Cyndi Osche

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Margaret Adams

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I was in the market for a new insurance company 3 yrs. ago and after alot of calls to local agencies I checked out Humphrey Insurance. My needs are met at a great price. Always helpful. Outstanding service. Great people.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Dan Kaluza

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

great place with people who care.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Roger Marple

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Stephanie's No.1 in my book. She's been very good at keeping my insurance as low as she's allowed, for both home and auto.
About a year ago, I was behind a large pick-up truck that was going to be leaving a parking area onto Rt.20. All of a sudden he decided to back up and rammed the front of my car. He didn't speak english so had apparently called someone who could. That young man gave me a card of 'his' insurance company which meant almost nothing, but also a name and ph.#. Since I was a mile from my insurance co., I stopped to see Stephanie to see what to do then. She's a true Sleuth. She sure found who the pick-up driver was and more info for me to get my car repaired instead of being left in the lurch, with the small piece of information that I'd been given from the young man (that came to help the driver of the truck. She's wonderful and kind.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

carol martin

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

(Translated by Google) Very friendly and professional service and communication

(Original)
Servicio y comunicación muy amable y profesional

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Joel Reyes

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Very dependable . Very please with their service and knowledge.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Ray Mattson

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Always friendly and helpful.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Darcy Wright

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

L. Kevin McGinnis

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I met Stephanie in the AM and presented her with my current auto and homeowner's policy. A short time later, she offered me a package that saved me roughly 35%. The policies matched or exceeded my current coverage. It was a no brainer to change to Stephanie and Humphrey Insurance. Highly recommended.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Michael Brown

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Toni Prasek

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Stephanie Carroll

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Stephanie Carroll

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I feel that Humphrey Insurance helps to resolve a problem that you may have in a timely matter. The staff is very friendly and determined to find a solution for you. I would recommend this company if you are looking for insurance. They are very efficient, timely and organized.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

queen marsh

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Humphrey Insurance Agency has been a pleasure to deal with after using some of the “other” big gimmick companies! Having a real person to talk to when I need my agent is priceless to me these days! Stephanie has always replied quickly & professionally & seems to really have her clients best interest in mind!

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

James Smith

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Humphrey Insurance Agency is outstanding with customer service and Insurance prices .

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Jeremy Carroll

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I've had all my insurance needs with Humphrey Insurance for 42+ years. My father also always had Humphrey Insurance. For all your needs, any situation, they have always been there for my family. Auto, Home & Business. No matter where you are located.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Steve Swanson

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

It's early in the game, but Stephanie has been helpful, thorough, courteous, and friendly.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Dick Schelat

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

It was a pleasure to work with you. Everything was explained to me.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Anet Adao

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Always helpful with our insurance needs. Goes the extra steps to help us.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Daniel Calaway

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

WOW! That’s all I can say. We were looking to possibly change insurance carriers. We reached out to Humphreys Insurance Agency, because they actually have agents you can meet face to face. Talked to Tom on the phone first then Stephanie. Stephanie made the transition go so smoothly. She answered every question and concern. If you’re looking at just getting a new quote, changing carriers or want to actually see your agent, I highly recommend Humphrey Insurance Agency.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

C Webb

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Very nice answered all my questions very good experience

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Alexander Arvanites

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Made 1 phone call and the next day I was in the office signing paperwork for my new insurance policy. Saved just about $500. Steph was very helpful and friendly to say the least. Would like to give a shout out to Sue for getting the ball rolling.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Jason Bernardo

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Agent at Humphrey in Ashtabula, Tom Jackson, always prompt and informative in responses to my questions. Had an urgent problem and he solved it. Thank you!

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Dennis Kane

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

I switched my home and auto insurance through Humphrey. I was shocked and thrilled that I'm saving half of what I was paying before. Stephanie was friendly and very prompt in assisting me and returning my calls.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Valerie Markgraf

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

It was so easy to switch from my old insurance company .

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Antoinette Jones

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Stephanie was excellent to deal with. Kind, patient and very knowledgeable. Highly recommended.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

john schmaltz

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Great insurance company. Very responsive and quick to answer questions and to provide helpful advice.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Jim H

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

My request for car insurance was re-routed from my usual insurance company to Stephanie at Humphrey Insurance. She provided me with a quote and then I asked my usual insurance company to quote and there was enough of a difference that I stayed with Humphrey. Stephanie did an excellent job of explaining everything to me and helping me become comfortable with a new car insurance company.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Nancy Snyder

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Stephanie is a wonderful agent at Humphrey Insurance. She is very willing and knowledgeable to get you the most for your money plus lots of extras.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Gloria Boyd

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

They are very professional and quickly had me a quote for my home and auto.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Trey Reed

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Stephanie was a pleasure to speak with and got me an extremely reasonably priced insurance. Even when my phone started acting up and I couldn't make calls, she patiently worked with me through emails to complete the process.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Tracy Tisdale

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Jeff Locher

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

Very business like and straight forward.

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

David Nolan

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

laura stroud

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Colleen Knapp

inverted-commas.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png
rating.png

google (2).png
POLICIES_HOME_IMG.jpg

Michael Parsons

WHYUS_GRADIENT.png

WHY US?

When

life happens,

Humphrey

handles it...

Quickly!

Trust is at the heart of everything we do. Accidents, surprises, questions, gaps, claims, changes, this is where a good agency earns its keep. We bring the know-how, the options, and the calm.

We're not just here for life's surprises - we're constantly working behind the scenes to keep you protected. From reviewing your coverage as life evolves to staying ahead of industry changes, we're always focused on your best interests.

HAPPY TO PROTECT YOU.

bottom of page